Equipment Failure: France and the US Military
I often tout "a key piece of machinery" as a key disruption example for the "disasters and disruptions" definition of business continuity. The news this week has a great demonstration of how that played out on two levels.
You might have heard that the French government determined that a cyberattack caused freezers in stores to malfunction (i.e. set temps too high), spoiling the food, was orchestrated by Iran. That's a key piece of machinery that failed and had a major impact on operations. The many things the IoT (internet of things) is good for (efficiency, cost savings, automated maintenance) is countered by increased risk (cybersecurity vulnerabilities, interoperability of devices, privacy concerns).
For years (at least since 2018) I have heard people - smart, in-the-know, people talk about food terrorism as the next big attack point. This would be a small example of that because it was limited in size and scope. Perhaps this was a proof of concept attack, like some water supply attacks have been: proof it can be done.
Or was it?
Just yesterday I read in military.com how in August, freezers across a few commissaries set to defrost mode overnight, spoiling the food it had and causing the commissaries to sell dry goods only, directing families to buy other things out in the community. At first they thought it was a weird coincidence (first problem) without attributing it to a common issue. Then the French news came out. They US military are now working with the French on investigating the occurence, suspecting that maybe it was a cyber incident.
What struck me is, even though the military has been aware of digital controls operating physical assets being a risk, they never thought it was a cyberattack. They're now updating the software and closing off some vulnerabilities to be on the safe side while figuring out if it was a malfunction or deliberate act.
While this joint investigation is ongoing, the challenge is whether they can keep refrigerated food available and prevent another disruption. I like to always say I don't care about the why/how, I care about the what -- the impact. If it was a malfunction, it can happen again. If it was a cyberattack, it can happen again. The end result is wasted food and loss of access to customers.
This event may or may not be a one-off. Don't treat it like one. That's basically saying, "oh this won't happen again!" and doing nothing about it. Having a plan in place in case allows them to keep the cash flowing and doors open. It's business continuity!
So what's the lesson? Look at your IoT equipment seriously to protect it AND make a plan for what happens if it fails.




Comments